February 25, 2015 By Vance Shaw, M.D.
Addicts are the pariahs of our society. The disease of addiction forces them to do things that are out of character and humiliating. It forces otherwise good people to do things to hurt themselves and their families. It sometimes even forces them to do things that cause them to go to prison or, in extreme cases, die. No one would choose that. But the drive to feed the addiction is stronger than the desire of a starving man to find food. It is far stronger. We would not fault a starving man for stealing a loaf of bread, yet it is a felony for an addict to stave off his addiction.
Because of what addicts do while in the throes of their addiction, addicts are filled with guilt and shame. They frequently have lost the affection and respect of loved ones, and are frequently incapable of supporting their families. Again, no one would choose to do that. It is thrust upon them by factors outside of their control like genetics or emotional trauma. A large percentage of rape victims become addicts. They did not choose to be raped, nor did they choose to become addicts.
But because addiction is a disease of the brain, it is impossible to use your brain to fix it. Any addiction counselor or addiction specialist will tell you that in most cases it is impossible for the addict to stop using on their own. They have to have help. To humiliate and incarcerate them does nothing but further damage the self integrity they need to get better, worsening the problem. Shame never cured an addict.
Addiction, like any other disease, needs appropriate medical treatment using sound scientific practices, not amateur conjecture. Many people believe you can punish an addict into recovery. This is simply not the case. Study after study has proven that. Addicts need support to mend the psychological wounds and reestablish a normal life. You would not force someone with a broken leg to walk on it in the false belief that exercising it will make it stronger. First you have to let the broken bone mend, or you will just do more damage. Likewise in many medical conditions medications are essential for treatment and recovery. Diabetes and high blood pressure frequently need more than just diet modification and exercise to obtain successful outcomes. Also, other diseases of the brain like schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and even depression are treated with medications. We are usually excited when science provides us with new medications to treat a lethal condition. Yet when it comes to scientifically proven, successful treatments for addiction, they are received with suspicion and scorn, again due to our prejudices about addiction.
As a society we must get over this prejudice and hatred towards addicts. After all, addiction can hit anyone, from doctors and lawyers to ministers and even heads of state. We must use scientific evidence upon which to base our treatments, not long held biases and prejudices. The United States has one of the highest addiction rates in the world, primarily due to our dysfunctional attitudes towards the disease of addiction. We must change that. We must all realize that addiction is a disease, and treat it as such, not treating it as a moral failing for which the addict should be punished.
Vance Shaw, MD
Board Certified by The American Board of Addiction Medicine
Filed Under: Addiction, Vance Shaw MD
Education and Resources
Resources for Medical Emergencies
For all medical emergencies, please call 911
Poison Control Centers:
Poison Centers offer free, confidential medical advice 24 hours a day, 7 days a week through the Poison Help line at 1.800.222.1222
Tennessee Department of Human Resources:
“Tennessee Department of Human Resources is responsible for administering numerous services throughout Tennessee, including Families First, the state’s Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) program, Food Stamps (now known as the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program or SNAP) , Child Support, Child Care Licensing, Child Care Assistance, Adult Protective Services, and Rehabilitation Services. With 133 office locations, DHS is one of the few state agencies with offices in all 95 counties.”
Frontier Health’s Crisis Response Team:
Frontier Health’s Crisis Response team fields any mental health emergency calls. Please call 877.928.9062.
Appalachian Counseling Centers
2412 Susannah Street Suite 6
Johnson City TN 37601
Phone number 423-461-0111 or 423-461-0112
Copyright © Medical Care Clinic of VA. All rights reserved.
501 Watauga Ave
Johnson City TN 37601